The 870 is a great gun but you should also look at the Browning BPS. Right now Browning has a 75 dollar rebate on all BPS 12 gauge 3.5" shotguns. This rebate comes directly from Browning so if you shop around you can get a really good deal. Personally, I like the 3.5" guns. They are not required but I can shoot 3" or 2.75" ammo if I want.