Amish people have to follow the same rules as other hunters.
Rem. I feel for you.............I've been dealing with the Amish for 15 years........I finally got them to understand what the word "posted" means. It took a lot of time, and threats, but I finally got them to understand!!!
What a lot of people don't understand, is that they are "slob" hunters! They get 10-20 guys, do drives, and kill anything they see.
I'm also quite sure they follow their own rules................they kill deer in the "off" season...........The sad part is, their just as happy to kill a button buck as they are a 12 point.
My best bet of getting a good buck is during archery. Not that many Amish bow hunt, and the ones that do have a little trouble with "scent" control.
