Hi, Smokpole.

I was in the same boat with you until I puchased a Summit Goliath today. I had researched all the brands and models, features and prices. No matter how much time you invest in your research, there is going to be a trial period before you determine if you made the right decision. By the way, I agree with your four criteria for tree stand selection. I don't think any other hunter would disagree as well. However, two additional factors should be considered: 1) what physical shape you are in and 2) what distances will you be packing the stand.

In the end, I chose the Summit Goliath over my two other semifinalists; the Grand Ol'Man and the Lone Wolf seat climber. The Ol'Man was least expensive and the Lone Wolf was most hi-tech in manufacture and least weight. All three ranged from 19 - 22 pounds. I chose the summit, for the following reasons: 1) I wanted the most comfortable stand that I could stay in all day, 2) I wanted the fewest steps involved in getting set-up, and 3) I wanted the most quietest stand with the fewest moving parts. In the end, the Summit came out tops in my selection. Did I make the best selection? Only days in the woods will answer this question. However, if I'm not satisfied, I will continue to buy different stands until I find the right one. These things are not like cars where we get to test drive them.

Good Luck with your selection and Happy Hunting !