If it was my buck and I went through all of this and new in my own mind it was a lethal hit and darn sure it was the same deer ,than I wouldn`t give a darn what the rest of you thought I would know in my mind I had taken it fair and square and the yotts got a taste of my buck so we will probably never know and it shouldn`t matter to him if it makes the bbok if he truly believes it is his.