akbound

Hi GOINHTN,

Of the three manufacturers mentioned, Taurus, S & W, and Ruger, I think undoubtedly the Ruger Super Redhawks are strongest. But, depending on your intended use and application it may or may not be the best choice.

If you are looking for a "primary hunting tool" and may be considering mounting a scope then the Super Redhawk is probably the way to go. But if you are considering one chambered in .44 Magnum then maybe even the standard Redhawk is worth an extra look. It too comes with rings/integral bases, is somewhat lighter than the "Super" edition and plenty strong enough for a steady diet of maximum loads.

If you are looking for a somewhat lighter framed .44 Magnum which will still handle the hunting chores then the S. & W. models 29 or 629 will work well. They do take more effort if you choose to mount a scope. And won't digest the diet of heavy loads as well as the heavier framed guns.

The Taurus is somewhere in between in frame weight. But also a good hunting revolver and comes ported standard.

I am going to purchase a large bore revolver for everyday carry when I spend my time outdoors in Alaska. I am in fact looking hard at the Taurus. It is available in .41 Magnum, .44 Magnum, .454 Casull, and .480 Ruger. But what I like about it is that it is available in a 5" barrel...and the heavier calibers. I do not see its primary use as a "primary hunting arm"...but rather a defensive weapon (bears and less degree feral dogs/wolves). Yes, it could be used for hunting, and may in fact be used in that capacity within its limitations...but that is not its primary use.

The five years I lived in Alaska previously my everyday carry was a 4" Model 629. And I carried it with 328 grain hard cast lead. After a box of so of those shells I would need to tighten some of the frame screws...almost everytime. If I were to choose the .44 Magnum again I might opt for the 629 in a 4" barrel. Or maybe go as large as the Redhawk with the 5 1/2" barrel. But I very well may move up the caliber rung to either the .454 or the .480 and because I want something portable...I will then pick the Taurus Raging Bull with the 5".

So I guess what I am saying, is that which gun I would purchase would to a large degree be determined on how I envisioned primarily using it!

Good luck with your upcoming purchase!