Originally Posted by
jnicholes
Thank you. I’ll add that to my list.
I actually went to Sportsman’s Warehouse today and got the right powder you guys recommended. While I was there, I was looking at projectiles. While looking at projectiles, a big debate arose between my guns manual, Sportsmans Warehouse, and Traditions firearms customer service. I’m not sure who to believe, so I figured I’d ask you guys.
My gun manual said to not use conical or ball projectiles. This is a problem, because Idaho regulations requires you use those in muzzleloader only hunts. I contacted traditions firearms, and asked them about this. They said to use ball projectiles. However, Sportsmans warehouse said to not use ball projectiles, and use conical projectiles, because the balls tend the curve when shot.
The regulations for Idaho muzzleloader only hunts say that the projectile needs to be within 0.010 of an inch of the bore diameter, and must be made of lead with no sabots. Conical or ball.
Traditions firearms referred me to a website that sells many sizes of muzzleloader projectiles, all spherical, to meet the size requirement for the projectile. Sportsman‘s warehouse showed me one in the store that was conical. Traditions firearms said the ones in the store were too small to meet my requirement for 0.010 of an inch of the bore diameter.
In a nutshell, I am very confused. Could someone PLEASE help me out? What would be a good ammunition/projectile that meets my State requirements?
All of this is better answered by IdahoRon . He is right there in the thick of it and has been hunting Idaho forever . I dont think its as complicated as its being portrayed. I would tend to take the advice of Traditions before I put any salt into the advice coming from a guy at Sportsmans Warehouse . But I would listen and trust anything that IdahoRon has for advice before either Traditions or Sportsmans Warehouse.
So just doing a quick search on conicals and checking your regulations , this pure lead hollow point powerbelt fits the description . Its even shown on whats legal on their regulation examples. I have used this same bullet in copper in both my TC Encore inlines using 100 grains of powder ( 2 50gr pellets ) with superb accuracy . Since you have to use loose powder , I would start with this one trying 100 grains of powder first . Then lowering it to 90 grains to see if that load is more accurate. I can take 3 shots at 100 yards and keep them all inside a 2 inch bulls eye . But thats with a scope which you cant use . So sight in at 25 yards 1st and work your way up to 75 yards .
https://www.gunbroker.com/item/924370494
Here is another one that fits your regulations and gun . Its a heavier bullet . I have never used this one but it has terrific reviews.
Anything made by Hornady is usually quality
https://www.sportsmans.com/shooting-..._reviews_title