I'm of the same opinion as Oldtimr. A Judge would be fine for bunnines within 10 yards but beyond that the pattern opens up too much for reliable multiple hits on fast moving game. the Judge was designed as a self defense firearm for "across the room" distance. For that purpose a load of buck shot or other large shot it will take down just about any intruder. Accuracy with .45's is not too good. But then again, why use .45s when with a .410 shot charge you have enough.
I owned a Judge but after shooting in and testing it I sold it within 2 weeks. Its too bulky to be a carry gun and for sure not a hunting firearm.