Originally Posted by
Oldtimr
mrbb, the problem is, inlines do not even come close to being a primitive weapon. They are cartridgeless centerfire rifles. Especially the ones that use smokless powder. They too were once not allowed in PA's muzzleloader season.
I think you took me wrong here, I am SAYING that to me, modern In lines are NOT primitive weapons, there totally different firearms, than a true muzzle loader ever was!
and agree there darn close to modern center fire rifles, minus the front loading still!
I have Both types, and can see the fun in them, but I won't call them the same class of weapon, and thus why I said, maybe should be a season for each>
BUT that gets us into the BOW< recurve, Compound and X bow arguments then doesn't it LOL