Originally Posted by
BarnesAddict
I would suggest, I'm pretty certain I know what I'm doing. I have numerous friends who shoot competition and are extremely well educated and versed in making barrels, building rifles, mounting scopes and extreme accuracy. A few of them are standing record holders in many forms of shooting, from .22 pistols and rifles, military pistols and rifles, muzzleloader shooters and BPCR shooters. A good friend I shoot with at times, also a winning record holding scope shooter, shoots some CF rifle at 100yds at a target the size of this: o using a 42x scope and a 6oz trigger. Two friends hold standing records with multiple firearm types. Everything from Camp Perry to Governor's Cup winners. Believe me when I say, I'm well taken care of when it comes to competition shooters that can educate.
Muzzle brakes can and many times will, change the POI, between with and without them. However, the muzzle brake has nothing to do with causing a scope to break and certainly none of mine. Tens of thousands of rifles are fitted with muzzle brakes.
I'll clear something up about past broken scopes. For instance the Nikon Monarch scopes I've busted, none of which a muzzle brake was involved. One has to understand that I put many thousands of rounds down range with those scopes. Not just 20-50 rounds a year, but up to 2,000 rounds a year. So in reality, the Nikons, although they were each repaired twice, held up pretty well come to think about it.
The VX6 was mounted correctly and held for over a 1,000 rounds before breaking the first time. The second time, with the best and strongest mount and rings Leupold makes, less than 100. Maybe it was "that" individual scope as the tech suggested at Leupold, but it failed the second time.
I cant point you in the right direction what to use. But you definitely need to talk to some better people then you are. Theres good brakes and bad brakes for guns/scopes. The good news about the scope you ordered its built around directional recoil. That will definately help your problem. But you could also be using a poor brake?? There are downsides to your new scope just like any other. Poor eye relief, and not holding good poi. I noticed some guys welding there bases on there muzzleloaders on Hanks board. You might want to talk to some of those guys. Not sure why there doing it, but the more i think about it, it makes great sense using a brake. I can assure you, high pressure loads, and big caliber CF rifles with brakes will break scopes. I can only tell you what i know, what you do in the end is up to you.