I think people get WAY to hung up on what they "prefer". Stands or blinds, bow or bow gun, rifle or shotgun, shotgun or pistol, high or low, what ever.
What is good for hunting would be for people to decide DO THEY WANT TO HUNT OR NOT. Period. Do you WANT to hunt.
After that all the rest is easy. You read the rules, learn the rules, then follow the rules for hunting what you want to hunt where you want to hunt it. No tears in hunting, when you quit crying you are half way there.
Now just learn to hunt the animal and it pretty quickly is obvious what tools you need to best HUNT this animal what ever it is.