I understand what you are saying about it gives younger bucks the best chance to grow big but there isn't much mistaken can be done with a true mature buck whether it has 15 points or 5. as in the pic that was taken and posted of the mature 6 point.

trigger control is everything. also on another corner of discussion what is a trophy to me, you, your buddy, etc... all are all different but if you can only kill 1 buck a year then it is your choice on what you consider a trophy.