Well the winner in my book,which only includes bullets available to me,is the Hornady xtp 158 gr HP loaded to +P.
Under the same conditions as the earlier shots this bullet opened up as designed penetrated completely and retained a little more weight that the others.
I am not able to compete any longer but I know what moving and shooting is about. In competition it is fact that you can not miss fast enough to win.That might be true in other situations.
Talking about trained operators going head to head is one thing. Talking about Street punk holding a hi point sideways is another.
A fellow can't believe everything he reads. I read that 110 gr HP was the new best load for snub nose revolvers. Not so.