Good job calling him on this.

As somebody else mentioned, I' d have left the gutting for him. I just don' t see how somebody can shoot any deer, let alone P&Y buck and not want desperatly to find it. Confident or not about the shot, the deer was hit, period.

I hope your " buddy" comes around and gets some sense in him.

Your welcome to hunt my woods anyday. (Note: That' s an open invite, but don' t think i' ll let you sit in my best stand! )

Good luck with your situation MA Jay.

-BJ