Try to attend one of the major traditional shoots. There will be vendors with new bows, and lots of used bows to try out. There are some in Michigan and Indiana which aren't too far from you. They are listed in the recent 3Rivers catalog. www.3RiversArchery.com or [email protected]
My favorites so far are Navajo and Marriah. I hope to try a Checkmate soon.
Good luck, and have fun!