Originally Posted by
bronko22000
I don't want to get into a war on words with bullets because we all have our own opinions.
I shoot those 300 gr XTPs in .451" and .429" out of my 50s and also the 200 gr 10mm from my .45.
I've shot 10-12 deer with them and the farthest any one went was about 50 yard or so. So I have no complaints. As for performance, I've never found a bullet as they were all pass throughs but the internal damage was severe.
One buck I shot with a 200 gr 10mm bullet was a legitimate 200+ lb 10 point that only ran 35 yards before piling up. Both lugs destroyed and top of heart busted up.
For some reason, again my opinion, people think they need a premium bullet for deer size game. I don't believe they have evolved into some kind of armored super deer. Now if you get significantly better accuracy from a bullet like the Lehigh or if your state does not allow lead projectiles then by all means I'm all for using them.
Not everybody is talking about deer when they mention terminal performance. I know in the case of me, grouse, or Mike we're probably thinking about elk. What works on deer may not be good for elk.