HuntingNet.com Forums - View Single Post - grrw-ca rifles and pistols
View Single Post
Old 03-04-2016 | 04:35 AM
  #51  
Muley Hunter's Avatar
Muley Hunter
Giant Nontypical
 
Joined: Feb 2011
Posts: 9,557
Likes: 0
From: Colorado
Default

Originally Posted by bronko22000
Muley read this very slowly so you can comprehend. Regardless of twist rate a projectile will continue that rotation after it leaves the barrel. The barrel length has nothing to do with it. If that same 10" barrel had a 1:70 twist rate and you loaded it with say an 80 grain charge it would stabilize the ball the same as if it was fired out of a rifle. Lets make this so even you can understand. If you have two twist rates - a 1:60 and a 1:20 the projectile from the 1:20 will be rotating 3 times faster than the 1:60. At 10' from the muzzle the projectile from the 1:60 will have made 2 revolutions while the one from the 1:20 will have made 6. All the twist does is start the process. It doesn't matter if the barrel is 4" or 40".
Like I have surmised or assume. The faster twist in a pistol may only be necessary due to the lower velocity because of the lighter charge in order to stabilize the ball. That is the only logical explaination. Otherwise one could use a 1:20 twist in a rifle with an 80 grain or more charge and a PRB with good accuracy. But we all know that is not the case.
Wrong!! Since we're talking about a 10" barrel in a pistol with a much slower fps than the 35" barrel with a faster fps. They both turn the ball 1/2 turn in the barrel. At 100yds which one do you think will turn the ball more times? How about 25yds?

Tell us wise one. Why do you think pistols have a faster twist?

As for the stripping. A PRB won't strip the rifling if it's a deep groove. Faster twist barrels are normally made for conicals/sabots with shallow rifling. If a PRB is shot too fast in those barrels the grooves are too shallow for the PRB to hold on to. A PRB in a deep groove barrel won't strip even if it's on the fast side.

Once again I tried to help by answering a question, and get told i'm wrong and insulted by forum know it alls. This won't happen for much longer.
Muley Hunter is offline  
Reply