As i said if you have two that are basically equal except one penetrates more, the higher penetrating projectile gets my vote. There is a better chance of it performing better if the shot isnt perfect and you hit more bone than intended.

I usually wait for the beautiful broadside opportunity but deer dont always offer the perfect shot. A slight quartering will have a noticeable effect on penetration to the vitals.

Let say both are just 3 jugs, i would take the Barnes for one reason. I would not be finding any lead in my meat and the razor sharp petals are like a spinning death star.