I just want to throw out some ideas that would have been important to your decision making. You stated you haven't hunted either property, so you don't really know what the pressure will be 'til you hunt it. First question would be how much land is available to hunt in that locale and how many other hunters may come to it because there is no access in other regions? Secondly would be what seasons/weapons do you hunt with?
I would prove to myself what hunting competition there actually is before I'd speculate. Speculating only cuts you out of property that could be very productive.