Ok, gotta chime in. Actually it's Mottzs that got me to try this and I almost made it work on the first try so I'm all for it. I see a lot of arguments on here that involve folks all overe the country and they all butt heads over what works, what's right or wrong, safe, or ethical.
From what I can gather after quite a few years on here is that things are tremendousely different from one part of the country to the next. What is suicide to try in one part of the country is totally no big deal in another. You guys sometimes tend to beat each other up over every little idea that someone has when your both correct for the place where you live and hunt.
That being said I think this is a great technique to have in your arsenal, if your area allows it of course, and yeah it's definateley a Hail Mary option, but is really effective and one hell of a rush when it works.
What state did you try it in?