I'm not saying it's wrong one way or the other.
If you want deer meat and have an over population of hunters verse deer, then there never will be a quality herd to manage and select from.
If you can as well as people around you use QDM, it only reaps benefits and not hurt you.
People around us use it, it works well. We typically have a few 150+ and usually at least one booner shot in our valley evey year. Also have a lot of nice ones on cam that we only get once or twice on cam and never hear about someone shooting it.