I have a pair of Cabela's Inferno boots and Muck Boots Woody Elite. With the Muck Boots, my feet do get cold sometimes later on in the season here in Michigan. Overall I love the Muck Boots, because water is not a problem as long as it isn't over the top of the boot. I wear my Infernos for late season deer hunting and ice fishing. I've had them 2 years and I love them. My feet stay very warm most of the time. My feet did get slightly cold last week when ice fishing with them. It was -3 with a windchill of around -30, so everything was cold though. Just the other day I did have the top eyelet pop out of one boot but it should be an easy fix. I've had them for 2 years now and that's the first issue I've had.