Don't ask me how but I found out what the problem was. I put my centershot gauge on the riser, set the distance button to the string. When I flipped it over to check the alignment to the nocked arrow my arrow was way off. I had to move the rest in a good 3/8" of an inch to align it. It's a wonder my BHs were even hitting the target!
I went out and sighted the bow in with FTs at 20 yds, shot some FTs along side some new Slick Tricks, made a couple very minor adjustments and have the BHs hitting within and inch of the FTs. What a relief. I was so frustrated I was seriously thinking about selling the bow and getting a new one.