never used it but I have heard the swamp donkey products are decent. personally I dont bait because of where I hunt is in between 2 soybean fields but if I do you cant go wrong with apples. they smell the strongest and are proven and cheap if you have a farm near you that sells them in bulk. also sugarbeets are good to try mainly because they are big so theres plenty to eat and they take a long time to rot. but give that swamp donkey stuff a try it cant hurt.