They are better than nothing. If you have the chance try to get a set of real antlers, they do sound better. There are a lot of options out there, some of them are even a set of plastic antlers. When you are rattling, don't be worried about scaring deer away. Although this may happen, you will get the more aggressive deer to come in if you hit them together loudly. Also rake the brush around you. When you are rattling you are going to have to keep your eyes open. Some of the bucks you call in will come running in and you won't have a lot of time to get to your bow. I hope this helps.