That is a tough one, like you said they are both great binoculars. I like the Pinnacles at little better, for 2 reasons, they are lighter and they feel more comfortable holding onto. One advantage with the 7x42 Discoverer' s, is they will be a little brighter than the 8x42 Pinnacle' s. I would give up that extra light to be able to more comfortable if I had to hold them up, scanning all day.

Jon Jackoviak
The Optic Zone
www.theopticzone.com
[email protected]