Ya some 15 doller pack of wall mart broadheads is cheep metal and wont hold and edge for crap I dont like loose or mechanical blades because Machines fail and though it will work 98% of the time perfect as designed I dont want the one time I need them to work on maybe the not so greatest shot angle for it to fail. Not all mechanicals are the same My OLD man LOVEs Rage mecahnical broadheads though they are made extreamly well and make a HUGE hole its still mechanical, it can fail to open, fail to depoly correctly and give a chance for murpheys law to crap on your day. But with Fixed blade braod heads it takes the chances out of the equasion. Its still razor sharp and wont break or fail to depoly correctly because its one piece of metal it wont give. All in all its up to you I have given you to top names for both fixed and mechanical and two pro and cons. So im not being bais. Let us know how it goes and what you choose to do!