I own a browning BPS in 3 1/2 inch and I always keep a couple in my pocket for when i see or hear a goose. normally I shoot 3' s for duck. I think there is a very noticable difference, unless your using hevi shot 3' s. But thats expensive. Buy a gun that is versitile and decide for yourself, If your a big goose man you' ll be more than happy!!!