I have. A friend shot a nice buck with one and it was a complete pass thru. When he retrieved the arrow, the little rubber band was still on it and it was closed. It didn' t even open after burying into the ground. Deer was found by another hunter over a mile away, a week later.
I may stand corrected.......but do you think it' s possible that the o-ring rolled back up as the arrow was pulled out of the ground ?? I know they' ll do that on Mckenzie targets and will almost be set back perfect when their pulled out !