I' ve got an Ol Man and a Summitt. I' ve been hunting the Summitt so far this year. As far as ease and durability I think they are equal. As far as comfort I have to give the nod to the Ol Man. Another advantage of the Ol Man is that if you leave it out like I do your butt won' t get nearly as wet after a rain. The net seat just doesn' t hold much water as the Summitt seat. They are both excellant stands and I think you' d be pleased with either one.