From GBhunter' s brief information it sounds like the buck/doe relationship is way out of wack. The harvest of does would be a lot more helpful to the herd than the harvest of a yearling buck. Same amount of meat, the only thing missing is a small rack that nobody would put on the wall. You don' t know if you will see that specific buck in two or three years, but if you shoot him now you definitely won' t see him with a trophy rack.