A cut on contact BH would be a better choice. I would not use the trocar tip Muzzy with that set up. IMO there isn't enough KE to force the trocar tip thru a deer. Especially if a rib is hit. He would be better suited with a Muzzy Phanthom, Slick Trick Razortrick, or Magnus Stinger. Any of these 3 in the 100 gr version. My personal preference after taking 5 buck with them would be the Magnus Stingers. They fly beautifully and have a lifetime guarantee. You bend or damage it just send it back and they send you a new one. That is a plus. A minus with them is the alum ferrule. It will bend after a lot of shooting into the new layered target butts. My second choice is the Razor trick followed by the Phanthom. The razortrick is one tough BH that flies great. These however tend to be a problem with the target butts for practicing. The square back of the razortrick's blades makes it difficult to pull out and the phanthom's design the main blade sometimes comes off in the target.