Originally Posted by
BuckAlley
I'll give you my insight, being a easterner from upstate NY. Always been a avid whitetail hunter, turkey hunter, camper, etc. Archery is my passion. I researched for 3yrs on a western Colorado hunt. Not rich, middle road income, family, kids. I looked into guided, semi guided, drop camps, trespass fee's, and diy hunts. I was concerned about price, and having a good trip. I had NO Elk experience, never been outwest at all, and knew noone lived out west. I read alot, and decided if going to do it, do it so I don't have to worry about all the unknowns. It'd probably be a 1x thing. So I made the plunge and went fully guided. The preparations for a first time western elk hunt- archery fully guided was enough. I had a blast, I loved it. I had NO regrets. To this day I dream of those mountains, and scenery. Would I have enjoyed it in other ways. Sure, but who knows how much. If I knew more about it back then, sure I'd done different. I've been back 3 more times since, and have no problems with a DIY hunt. So I'd suggest its all in how much you know about the area, and your experience. Becasue trust me eastern to eastern hunter. The west, and chasing Elk is a whole different ball game! You'll be totaly amazed!
Here's another angle. Had you done a DIY. You'd have saved enough money to come do it again, and use the experience you learned the first time. Maybe two more times depending on what you paid for the hunt.
Did you get an elk?