As with anything "you need the right tool for the Job" & a .357 is not the right tool, will it put down a deer ? of course it will, will it put down a moose, Of course it will. The big question is why?? a 30/30 or .35 Remington (which I prefer) are just so much more capable, they are also easy on the pocketbook. another option is a RIFLED shotgun, H&R have them priced very reasonable, much preferable to the .357. I have just seen too many lost deer with the .357 PISTOL & I don't know anyone who uses .357 in a rifle (although it would be much preferred to the pistol) I understand in todays economy, money is tight, & that is just more reason to use the right tool, Remember,,, "only a rich person can afford cheap tools" JMOP Doc