If anyone has a problem with making a decision on which bird to go after the next morning, I think they should just consider themselves lucky that they have more than one bird to go after. Eenie, Meenie, Minie, Moe. Many of us find ourselves in the situation of not having any bird to hunt at all. Just pick one.
However, there are times I will be picky. I will let a jake walk if I know I have time to continue hunting. Last hunting day, that jake is dead.
Also, if I find myself with multiple toms in front of me, I will pick out the one that looks bigger or has the bigger beard if I can get the shot. Otherwise, it will be the one that offers the best shot.