I' m a firm beliver in Tink' s #69 but only when the time is right usually here in WV I use it from the 2nd week of November until the end of the rut.
I' m not sure what they are called but the little orange plastic bottles that Tink' s makes work really good. They have a wick in them and after the hunt you just push the wick back down and put the lid on and they are ready for the next hunt.
Have a great day!