In my opinion the best deer scent is no scent at all. I think a lot of so called deer attractants attract more hunters than deer. I had a doe estrous lure cost me the biggest buck that I have ever seen in the timber and since that day I have not used any type of deer scent since. He was following a doe right to my stand that was until the doe came upon the estrous scent I had out. She got really nervous around the scent and decided to go the other way taking the big P&Y buck with her. That was the last time I ever used any type of attractant while hunting. I think you are much better staying scent free and hunting sign and land terrain rather than looking for a magic scent in a bottle because their isn' t any!!!