Ive never used a scope with circles or dots...to me, its clutter and in my way. I had thought about getting one a while back, but after looking through it I decided not to.
I do just like BP does. I just make sure I know where my gun hits...and put the crosshair on it. I'll never (with my current setup) shoot past 150, so I don't have a need for anything special at this time. My gun is sighted 2" high at 50, and I'm in the kill zone for my range just by aiming on it. This is the same way I shoot my bow...I have one pin, and my bow is setup and tuned so I just hold on the kill zone within my given range. Takes the guesswork out of it. I like it simple I guess.
If I had to choose for longer ranges, I'd take the turret. I can see where it could potentially mess you up...but again, shooting out at 200, 250, etc...(for me) would take some calculating and I feel like I'd be on top of it. I guess someday maybe we'll see. You guys keep shooting 250-300 yds, I'm liable to get an itch to try it. LOL