Antlers
It's true and I say it all the time, "You can't eat the antlers".
However; if a 250# 8 pointer, at 125# spike and a 200# doe were to materialize in front of me with a hunting implement in my hands, I'd take the 8 pointer.
That said and with a single either sex deer tag, I will not wait on a chance at a buck if a 125# doe presented herself.
My $.02