I' m thinking two things when I first read the post:
1. Not picking a spot.
2. Shooting high because in elevated position.

But if you have not paper tuned yet?[:' (] But that' s OK. Test your broadheads and compare them to field point groupings and adjust your arrow rest until the two groups come together. The reson is because broadheads are much more susceptable to minor tuning inacuracies. If they group to the right of the field points, you can move your arrow rest left just slightly and they will move left towards the field points even though the field point groups seem to be in the same place.

Sounds like you are having a bad year. But you seem to be getting alot of shot opportunities. Your hitting to high and too forward tho if it' s in the shoulder. Aim lower a few inches behind the elbow or somewhere in that area. And pick a spot. A shadow, spot of fur, or whatever. That will really help to out in shooting game because there is no bullzye to aim for otherwise.