i spent a couple years trying Everything !!!!
with grim results, A friend made a good point we live in New England. the place you're getting your deer attractor from is where ??
Midwest down south dont know either way its not from new england deer?
different foods different smells,
Also how many others use it !! and the woods stink of every scent known to man from the local store , made sense
So I now use No scents other than what I can get locally and see way better results
the only thing I found that has worked is grab a bladder from a fresh deer deer kill or if you hunt multiple areas I will find droppings and dig soil from once place and make a mock at another now that if done right brings some really good attention I have had areas shredded, and shot a nice buck