Thanks again for the advice all. I ended up going with the Redfield 4-12X40 with the Acu-Range reticule. The tipping points for me to pick this one were the reticule having the different aim points and the zoom range. I also liked that Redfield is a sibling company of Leupold. After getting the scope, the only thing that I do not like is the click on the scope adjustments. It is not crisp and has play when it goes back the opposite direction. Overall, I am happy with my purchase, but next time I will go into a gun store to look at the scopes hands on. I live in a small rural town and there is not a decent gun shop near so I made this order online.