can't say on the other 2 but the ruger in 358 that I have is a decent gun. It's a SS in a plastic stock, but it's a pretty good
tuperware stock. I shoots decent, trigger could be lighter but with the lawyers today at least it breaks clean. The only thing bad I can say about it is that it will not feed 180 grain bullets, but 200's up they run slick as a piece of smooth plastic on bare ice.