the last one is only a 3 year old for sure and is actually in very good shape. i am guessing he looks like that because of the cold, if you notice it says 12 degrees and his hair was all fluffed up to help him stay warm. i have other pictures of him where he looks fine and i saw him in person this week and he is healthy but definitely lost some weight from the rut. he was in a lot worse shape last year and ended up going from around a 70 inch small racked 7 pointer to a 12 pointer this year so i am hoping he makes another big jump to next year