Ok I have a guy with two scopes that are basically brand new in packaging. He wants 100 a piece for them. Just wondering which one would be a better deal. The first is a:

Simmons .44mag 4-12x44

the second one is a:

BSA catseye 4-16x44

Which ever one I decide to get will be going on a thompson center encore. Please give me your honest opinion on both scopes, and your pick. Thanks