Oh my goodness... that just would never work at my house. Kidding of course. Families have to decide what they need the most and then purchase accordingly. I am sure Jess has reasons for her feelings.

I would take the Apex as it might be more rain proof. Also get some rain gear. A good rain jacket is a must. Also water proof (not water resistant) boots are a must. Your feet and socks get wet, you are all done in my book. Cabela's has some good rain suits on sale from time to time. Watch their bargain cave.