This is GREAT!
I just did a similar test in my woods, only I was comparing Natgear to ASAT.
I was thinking about buying more,new camo or dusting off the old ASAT and getting some new pieces to match.

The whole sticks and leaves thing just dosen' t do it for me.

I came up with similar results. To me, the ASAT was the clear winner.
And now I own several more $' s worth of ASAT