You are talking 60 seconds! The odds of this happening by two different deer are (in 60 seconds) is almost incalculable. It is almost certainly the same deer. If it were a different deer there would be some difference (come on guys, ever shoot two different deer that looked this much alike??) Shape, color, body shape, or some difference besides antlers, NO deer are the same!! heck I have seen 6 pointers coming down the trail and with a slit turn of the head it become an 8 or even a 10, each deer will have there own characteristics , some dark brown, some reddish, some more pointed in the face, Etc: but never the same, look at this deer, almost exactly the same, just the antlers out of "kilt" given the odds (I repeat, just the odds!!!) make these two deer to be one and the same. jmop Doc