hey, I think bottom line here is urine is urine. no it may not be a hot doe, or another buck but deer are curious animals like cats. they can't smell the urine and say oh not that was a hunter, gotta go. as long as we dont' leave our foul smell on branches and frm our boots they have no idea what it is, they just know somethings whizzin on my scrape and I am either gonna mount it or fight it.