Purely one guys opinion.....the .357 is a woefully inadequate deer cartridge from a revolver.....and some folks actually kill deer with it!

Very few guys can actually handle a .44 magnum...they have them but can't shoot them.....mostly ego trip!!!....a lot of talk!!!

The .41 Mag is powerful enough and is also tough to shoot....but a lot easier than a .44 mag....

I strongly recommend the .41 Magnum.....