Originally Posted by
bigcountry
come on man, don't be silly
On average taking out the hotshots who make mulie 60 yard shots, 30 yards is ethical with a compound on average. I am not talking about Bob (the rev) who does 100 exhibition shots, I am talking average.
On average, with an arrowgun from a rest, I would push that to 50 yards. I have shot em, and I was deadly at 60 yards. I am talking 4" groups.
270win, freehand, most hunters cannot hit the vitals at 100 yards. I crap you not. Most hunters go to the range once a year and shoot off bags. I am shocked sometimes when i see the orange army roll in the range in Oct. On a rest, effective range still is about 200 yards.
Here is what I tell everyone, 90% of the time, your effective range with longbow/compound/recurve in a hunting situation is 1/2 of what you can do in your yard. For me, I can consistently hit a 3d deer target up to 35 yards with a longbow. I think thats fairly decent. My honest effective comfortable hunting range is 18 yards.
With a compound, I can consistently hit a 3d target up to 50-60 yards. I try to make my effective comfortable range 30 yards.
I am not saying these are rules for all folks. But am saying on average.
Why won't you answer the question? We all know the answer but you can't come out and say it. That shows me a lot. But you still spelled it out and showed me that the xbow and compound are closer in range. I bet that hurt didn't it.
I think you are about 10 yards low on the compound and I would bet most on this forum would agree but thats your opinion.
I found this topic on a forum on your longest bow shot....many had sixty plus and some out to 100. I would never do it but it just shows many do. I also looked at a couple xbow forums and only a few had shots at 50 yards and most were around 30.
Here is the bow list....interesting to say the least.
http://www.archerytalk.com/vb/archiv.../t-792200.html